J
Jefferson T
December 22, 2021
What a steal!! Love these
These retail for $425 on the Allen Edmonds website.Got a size 13D for $190+ tax. Was concerned they would be factory seconds but shoes looked almost perfect.Only imperfection is on the Rubber sole, it appeared to be slightly off centered so one of the divots had stitching in it.Ordered the exact same pair off Allen Edmonds for $331 and they had the same rubber sole stitching issue PLUS the tan finish was uneven.So the Amazon shoes were actually better craftsmanship and $235 cheaper. What a steal!Unfortunately size D was too tight on both pairs. Normally I’d recommend getting sized at an Allen Edmonds store but there are none within 2 hours. So I have size E (wide) coming and will see if they fit better.Will also update review once I’ve had a chance to break them in.Final note is these are weather proof. In comparing them to another pair of non-weather proof shoes, the Walnut color was the exact same.I was concerned the weather proof walnut would be darker, but that wasn’t the case.
✔ Verified Purchase
Awesome Dress Boots
Solid book; no break-in periods, great design and excellent equally.
✔ Verified Purchase
F
Fritz T Cat
September 11, 2023
Most excellent boot. Strange pricing.
I needed a more formal boot than my 5.11 Combat Specials and I heard good reviews of Allen Edmonds online so I tried them out. Very grateful for the hassle free return policy on Amazon because if you don't get measured for dress boots at an AE store you may need to order several different sizes.I wear 9.5 wide or 10 D in all my regular boots and sneakers. The Chilli colored 10D AE boots were comically long and way too tight. I ended up with an 8.5XX wide and after wearing for an hour the set fit perfectly.The boots were flawless even though I got them for one of the lowest listed prices here. I clicked an hour later and the 8.5XXW were back to $430. Weird.But a great boot, just watch the sizing - they run long and tight.
✔ Verified Purchase
F
Freddie McAbee
August 31, 2025
Great quality shoe
Beautiful
✔ Verified Purchase
M
Michael O.
August 15, 2023
The Finest Boot I Own !
Allen Edmonds ! Handmade In Port Washington Wisconsin by folks who care . The Hamilton is an awesome boot with a smooth leather lining with just the right amount of broughing , and the Waterproof construction . Want to know the real advantage of AE shoes and boots is that they are 100 % recraftable , take care of them and they will last a lifetime !
✔ Verified Purchase
L
LUIS E.
February 19, 2025
Poor Quality and Craftsmanship
I expected high-quality craftsmanship from these Allen Edmonds wingtip boots, but they fell short in multiple ways. The color is completely off from the product images, with the "walnut" shade appearing cheap and unrefined. The material feels low quality, lacking the premium feel I expected.Additionally, the finishing is disappointing, with loose threads and poor stitching. The sole stitching showed wear after just one use, which raises concerns about durability. The branding on the sole is barely visible, making me question the overall authenticity and attention to detail.If you are looking for a reliable, well-crafted pair of boots, I would recommend exploring other options. These did not meet my expectations for quality.
✔ Verified Purchase
W
Wingshooter
March 26, 2022
Uneven color; color tone not as pictured
As expected, the shoe is well-built and looks great. What is somewhat disappointing is that the right shoe on my order is not evenly colored between sections, while the left shoe is fine. The color I received is more of a chocolate brown, and not the deeper, richer reddish brown in the picture. Polishing the lighter sections with black polish helped even out the color difference. Also, since I have large calves, the ankle collar creates some discomfort around my achilles tendon, and time will tell if it’s something I will get used to, or will cause pain and irritation on long days.
✔ Verified Purchase
