Eastland Women's Newbury Penny Loafer

(4.2)

1290 Reviews

Get it - $48.42

#commissionsearned

Specifications

Fabric type: 100% Leather
Origin: Imported
Sole material: Manmade
Outer material: Leather

The Eastland Women's Newbury Penny Loafer is a stylish and comfortable footwear choice that seamlessly blends classic design with modern comfort features. Handcrafted with a premium unlined leather upper, this loafer not only looks sophisticated but also molds to your foot for a personalized fit.

One of the standout elements of this shoe is its active memory foam comfort insole, which is designed to support and conform to the unique contours of your foot. This ensures that you can wear them all day long without discomfort. The textured TPR outsole adds to the appeal by providing excellent slip-resistance, durability, and shock-absorbing cushioning, making it suitable for various environments.

Features

Full-grain leather upper conforms to your foot for a custom fit
Soft, breathable fabric-lined upper and insole
Removable, padded OrthoLite comfort insole with patented moisture control for breathable, all-day wear
Flexible TPR rubber outsole for great comfort, slip resistance, insulation, and durability
Heel Height: 2 inches

Pros

Custom fit provided by full-grain leather
Excellent breathability due to the fabric lining
Comfortable cushioning from the memory foam insole
Versatile design suitable for casual and dressy occasions
Reliable slip-resistance enhances safety on various surfaces

Cons

Higher price point compared to some competitors
May require a break-in period for optimal comfort
Limited color options available

Related Product

Sale-37%

Eastland Women's Sonya Penny Loafer

$36.0~~$0.0~~

Sale-14%

Eastland Women's Classic II Penny Loafer

$86.48~~$100.0~~

Eastland Women's Debora Loafer

Unlock Price

Sale-8%

Rockport Women's Kacey Penny Loafer Flat

$36.99~~$0.0~~

Sale-37%

Lucky Brand Women's Floriss Penny Loafer

$62.37~~$99.0~~

Cole Haan Women's Stassi Penny Loafer

$115.5

Sale-33%

Cole Haan Women's Stassi Penny Loafer

$80.4~~$120.0~~

Sale-67%

Rockport Women's Kacey Penny Loafer Flat

$35.17~~$105.0~~

Sale-41%

White Mountain Women's Gunner Penny Loafer

$50.25~~$85.0~~

Aldo Women's Loafer

$65.0

KORK-EASE Women's Modeste Heeled Penny Loafer

Unlock Price

White Mountain Women's Wallace Moc Penny Loafer

$89.0

Sale-9%

Eastland Women's Seneca Boot

$100.0~~$110.0~~

Eastland Women's Alexis Oxford

Unlock Price

Eastland Men's Karl Loafer

$29.99

LifeStride Women's, Turnpike Loafer

$38.42

Eastland Women's Charlestown Sandal

Unlock Price

Sale-14%

LifeStride Women's, Nominate Loafer

$34.79~~$0.0~~

BCBGeneration Women's Mackie Loafer

Unlock Price

Naturalizer Women's, Mariana Loafer

$57.82

Eastland Women's Double Down

$84.97

ALDO Women's Ibreda Loafer

Unlock Price

LifeStride Women's, Lolly Loafer

$57.44

Sale-21%

ALDO Women's Brixtonn Loafer

$62.97~~$80.0~~

Taos Women's Upward Loafer

Unlock Price

Sale-37%

Kensie Women's Val Loafer

$25.28~~$40.0~~

VANELi Women's Kimmo Loafer

Unlock Price

Sale-8%

TOMS Women's, Cara Loafer

$72.0~~$0.0~~

REVITALIGN Women's Bella Loafer

$99.95

Vionic Women's, Charlotte Loafer

$139.95

Aquatalia Women's Calandra Loafer

$318.95

Eastland Women's Buck Oxford

$109.95

Sale-40%

LifeStride Women's, Sonoma Loafer

$47.99~~$79.95~~

Sale-53%

Naturalizer Women's, Elin Loafer

$57.0~~$120.0~~

Sale-9%

Naturalizer Women's, Corrine Loafer

$81.64~~$0.0~~

ALDO Women's Brixtonn Loafer

$90.0

Sale-44%

LifeStride Women's Zee Loafer

$44.98~~$79.95~~

Vince Women's Lennox Loafer

$245.52

Naturalizer Women's, Cabaret Loafer

$125.0

LifeStride Women's Logan Loafer

$65.89

Easy Slip-On Design for All-Day Comfort – Price, Ratings, Reviews & Sales Insights

Product Name	Price	Rating	Review Count	Expert Score	Sales Last Month	Buy
Eastland Women's Classic II Penny Loafer	$86.48	(4.2)	4809	93	10	Get it on Amazon
LifeStride Women's Zee Loafer	$44.98	(4.2)	2360	91	10	Get it on Amazon
Cole Haan Women's Stassi Penny Loafer	$115.5	(4.2)	831	87	10	Get it on Amazon
Cole Haan Women's Stassi Penny Loafer	$80.4	(4.2)	853	87	10	Get it on Amazon
TOMS Women's, Cara Loafer	$72.0	(4.2)	686	87	10	Get it on Amazon
Eastland Women's Buck Oxford	$109.95	(4.2)	317	87	10	Get it on Amazon
Eastland Women's Seneca Boot	$100.0	(4.2)	452	86	10	Get it on Amazon
LifeStride Women's, Sonoma Loafer	$47.99	(4.2)	172	86	10	Get it on Amazon
Naturalizer Women's, Corrine Loafer	$81.64	(4.2)	10	86	10	Get it on Amazon
Rockport Women's Kacey Penny Loafer Flat	$36.99	(4.2)	448	85	10	Get it on Amazon
Lucky Brand Women's Floriss Penny Loafer	$62.37	(4.2)	105	85	10	Get it on Amazon
Rockport Women's Kacey Penny Loafer Flat	$35.17	(4.2)	465	85	10	Get it on Amazon
White Mountain Women's Gunner Penny Loafer	$50.25	(4.2)	239	85	10	Get it on Amazon
Aldo Women's Loafer	$65.0	(4.2)	216	85	10	Get it on Amazon
Eastland Men's Karl Loafer	$29.99	(4.2)	12	85	10	Get it on Amazon

What Customers Say

Peia Edgerly

October 22, 2025

5 / 5

Well made

With a little stretch with the stuffing paper, was able to widen the left shoe. They fit well now. Comfortable and attractive.

✔ Verified Purchase

ginny

April 21, 2024

5 / 5

Comfortable, but they run a tad big

I've been wearing these shoes at least once a week for the last several months and overall I really like them. I have an average width foot and wear between a 7.5 and 8.5 depending on the shoe. Usually, a size 8 fits perfectly but these feel a little more like an 8.5 in a wider shoe. I have to wear thick socks to keep my foot from sliding around. Even so, they're still comfortable and they seem durable.

✔ Verified Purchase

David

January 22, 2023

4 / 5

Comfortable!!

I am on my feet for hours and hours a day at work. I needed something with a bit of a heel, and these are fantastic! So comfortable, don’t squeeze my toes together, the right width, lovely. I didn’t give five stars, because I feel the material could get scratched and messed up easily. But if you need a comfy “heel,” get these!

✔ Verified Purchase

Andrea R.

December 17, 2015

5 / 5

Good to know Eastland has maintained it's quality

First- let me say after reading the reviews- I wasn't sure what I would get- some claimed they got shoes all scratched up. It was a gamble on the size as well.- The shoes I received were pristine in condition- no scratches, gouges, etc. Very nice. Beautiful color. This feels like the quality that I've had in an Eastland over 20 yrs ago! I was surprised by the quality because it seems all the good brands have compromised their quality. No glue blobs, no stitching loops exposed, this appears to be a very well made shoe. I even took the insole out and it's very trim and cleanly constructed on the inside too.-Sizing- this is always a gamble-I normally wear a size 10. I have wide feet. I generally get rubbing on top of my foot if the ball of my foot is too tight in a shoe width wise. I was worried the 10s would be too narrow there and uncomfortable. As far as my sizing goes- for comparison- I never have luck with a dress shoe from Naturalizer or Clarks- all those cute narrow footed shoes, sometimes an Aerosole if it's wide and an open back- same goes for the store brands from Fred Meyer or Kohl's. But I can wear a size 10 Sperry casual (go figure). Based on my experience with other dress shoes and some of the reviews- I chose to go up to an 11. IF there had been a 10.5 - these would be 100% perfect. The 11s are just a skosh too big- but nothing a thicker sock won't fix. They don't pull off my heel and there is plenty of room in the toe box and ball of my foot area.My foot is not sliding around or shifting or any odd rub areas. I'm not really a hose stocking person so the larger size made sense. To me- a too small shoe is miserable and ends up making my back hurt and while I do think these would have stretched to fit- I can't stand breaking in leather shoes. It's annoying. Although in all fairness I think breaking in a true quality leather shoe should not be confused with all the "manmade" crap that is out there- so who knows? I'm happy with the size I chose.- These look nice- the heel and slightly chunky sole are modern without a total throwback to the overly chunky shoes the late 90's and early 2000's. The heel height is doable and realistic. I have short legs for being tall and this helps my hemline on pants.- I will currently give these 5 stars- this is a very well made shoe. How it wears and if it lasts longer than 6 months will be the next test.- I will gladly call this a classic loafer from a quality shoe maker that has transcended time. :D

✔ Verified Purchase

BGSaratoga

July 21, 2025

3 / 5

Disappointing

I should have paid more attention to other reviews. I love the look of these shoes but just could not get them to fit right and feel comfortable. They rubbed the underside of my ankle bone so I added pads in heel to raise my foot a bit - helped but not enough. Also slipped badly at the heel so I inserted little non-slip things - still slipped badly. Unfortunately had to return them ☹️.

✔ Verified Purchase

Mary Self

January 07, 2026

5 / 5

Very good quality

Very good shoes thank you

✔ Verified Purchase

M. McElveen

July 17, 2025

5 / 5

Awesome shoes

My second pair of these. Great dressy casual comfortable shoe. Heel height is not a problem with my high arches and doesn't feel like heels. Leather quality is great and they look good for years. Great Value for quality and comfort.

✔ Verified Purchase