If you’re debating Rothy’s vs. dupes, read this first!
I’ve tried Rothy’s ($159), TINGRISE ($27), and these Frank Mully flats, and I can honestly say Frank Mully is the clear winner. The fit is more forgiving in the toe box, which makes a huge difference if you have bunions or wider feet. Rothy’s rubbed against my pinky toe and bunion, making them uncomfortable for long wear, and definitely not worth the splurge.The Frank Mully flats, on the other hand, are cushioned, stylish, and so comfortable I can wear them all day. The quality is impressive for the price, and they look almost identical to Rothy’s. TINGRISE was cute but flimsy and not supportive for regular wear.👉 These photos are from their first wash, and they held up beautifully — another reason I’ll keep buying these.Bottom line: Save your money — skip the Rothy’s and grab these instead. I’ll never splurge again when Frank Mully delivers comfort, style, and value all in one.
✔ Verified Purchase
T
tami hawkins
November 28, 2025
Worth every penny!
These shoes are the best! I am new to wearing flats like this and have gone around and around with what size fits. I am a solid 8 and these {size 8} fit me beautifully. I have a normal size foot, not wide and not too narrow. They are so comfy right out of the box, nice cushion on the bottom. These can be worn dressy or casual which I like. They seem well made and my feet weren't too hot wearing them, so that makes them all the more comfy. I want these in all the colors and wish they had more color choices. Great shoe!
✔ Verified Purchase
Awesome but size accuracy is questionable
I just received these. They are so comfortable, cute and quality. I got on Black Friday for half the price (yay!) Finally arrived and the size recommendation is questionable. I think I should have ordered half size up. Unfortunately I can’t exchange but return and re-buy. Which means regular price. Boo. I am normally a 6, in some brands a 6.5. I ordered a 6, now wishing I got a 6.5. I recommend if you’re unsure, and the item is deeply discounted, order both sizes and keep the one best suited for you. I imagine they’ll stretch out but bummed the size isn't perfect. Five stars for the product but took away one for lack of ability to exchange (which is an option for some Amazon retailers).
✔ Verified Purchase
M
melanie gatdula
April 10, 2025
Don’t get Rothy’s. Get these!
These flats are the most comfortable flats I’ve tried! I could usually fit between size 6-6.5 which varies between each shoe, so I decided to order a 6.5 since the reviews mentioned sizing up. However, I found the fit to be a bit loose, so I ordered a size 6 which seemed like it would be somewhat tight at first especially near my toes, but after walking in it for the first day, the fit loosened up and now it fits perfectly. It actually loosened up quite a bit, so I would say if you’re between sizes, go with the lower size. I also have somewhat wide feet so I would say these pointed toe flats are extremely accommodating for even wide feet which is surprising. Most pointed toe flats tend to squish my toes but these are very flexible and give my toes room. They are also so beautiful I just want to wear them to work everyday. I feel like a lot of flats look a bit dorky and ridiculous on me, but I actually love how these look! At first I was debating on spending a lot more on Rothy’s but I’m so glad I went with these instead for less than half the price. A lot of things on amazon can be a hit or miss, but I would say these are one of the best purchases I’ve made in terms of quality and price. I also don’t tend to usually buy flats that have a back on them like these and tend to buy ones that are open in the back like slippers because I always have issue with the back rubbing on my heel and causing it to bleed, but I do not have that issue with these flats at all. I’m now considering buying more in other colors because I love it that much
✔ Verified Purchase
As expected
Color is as shown, and they fit as expected.They are true to size.I wear a size eleven, and I got a size eleven.Very comfortable would highly recommend.
✔ Verified Purchase
Cute
3 stars because it took a few tries to get the right size. Every color from this company fits differently. That is frustrating and time consuming. But they’re cute and comfortable.
✔ Verified Purchase
T
Tracy B
November 18, 2025
High Quality and Comfortable!
Better than Rothy's. I wear a 7.5-8, and ordered the 7.5. Fit perfectly and I like the arch support that most flats don't have! Will definitely get another color in these soon!
✔ Verified Purchase
