N
NinjaSquirrel
July 27, 2025
Instantly Obsessed
First let me say that it's impossible to take a pic of your own foot and have it look flattering. That being said, they look much better in person. I first bought my husband a pair of the man version for our cruise next week to Mexico (our excursions involve rocky trails and beaches etc) and I got jealous of how much he loved his (he isn't the excited about shoes kind of guy usually) and it made me want a pair too. So after tons of reviews and researching the girl versions, I decided on these, and im glad I did. The big question was size for me. Some said runs big, others run small, so I chose my usual size, which is 10 in everything except sneakers, where I'm 10.5. It was a tuff decision since these are kind of both sandal and sneaker, and when I first put them on I thought they were too small. All I have to say is really work the bungee laces and adjust and walk, then adjust, and bingo....perfect fit. I was worried about my bunions, but these don't hurt, and im sure as soon as I get them wet and walk around they will totally mold to my feet completely. I think if I would have went bigger, they wouldn't hold my foot secure like these do. So my advice, go with your sandal size, adjust the bungee laces, and go spray them with a hose and walk around, which is what I'm going to do right now. Hope this helped, and if you're on the fence, go for it. They are worth it.
✔ Verified Purchase
R
Robin in FL
September 23, 2025
True fit. Comfy. Sturdy
Great shoe. Went hiking in rough terrain in them. Sturdy. Comfortable
✔ Verified Purchase
If you need a soft step
I just got and put on my Astoria West closed toe sandal from Keen color desert sage/multi. They look great! Cute! Not clunky at all. What impressed me the most is the cushion these shoes provide. Take it from me, someone who has been living in only Oofos for the past 2 years because of needing the squishy cloud like feel to relieve foot pain. I can't believe how comfortable the souls of these shoes are. It's really hard to find a squishy soft soled shoe with significant thickness. The top and sides of this shoe are comfortable also. No toes are sticking out. Due to several reviews I decided to buy these in a size 8. I normally wear a 7 or 7 1/2 in shoes but, I do wear a size 8 in sneakers. This size 8 Astoria fits nicely so I recommend using your sneaker size. Because of their cloud like squishiness they conform to your feet and arch. I do feel that if you have a very high arch and/or a chunky foot these would probably be tight on you. My feet are thin and my arch is low. My review may be premature being that I haven't worn them outside yet but, what's making me feel so good about them is the cushion in the heel and the ball of my foot. I have so much foot pain that if I didn't feel this cushion I would actually be afraid to go outside in these because of knowing I'd end up in pain but, I'm not afraid at all to go outside in these and I'm looking forward to it!I have an old pair of keen closed toe sports sandal (size 7 1/2) that I've been really needing to replace but I haven't found any that were comfortable. I am so glad I went ahead and ordered these online!So far so wonderful!! I don't want to take them off.
✔ Verified Purchase
Super comfortable good support
Probably the more comfortable keen sandals. Funny how it says waterproof on the shoes but the neoprene and fabric stays wet until dried out. Great arch support and cushion.
✔ Verified Purchase
M
Mrs Upjohn
August 17, 2024
Heads-up: My usual size fits perfectly in these
Keen Astoria West SandalLove them so far! Super comfortable, very lightweight, and cute. Got the scarlet ibis or whatever it is, a nice red. They may not be the best choice for rough trails, but for all my city walking, casual wear, easy hiking, beach walks, I think they'll be perfect. And they're cute enough to wear with a skirt or casual dress. We'll have to see how the white soles look over time.About Sizing: I wear an 8.5 M in all my other Keens but had heard these were smaller, so I first ordered a size 9. They were way too big for me. Replaced with my usual size, perfect. BUT I recently tried on some Keen Uneek and Uneek Astoria sandals at the Keen store, and in those I definitely needed to size up. For the Uneek Astoria, I needed a size 9. For th regular Uneek sandal, I was undecided between the 9 and the 9.5. I my experience the Uneek Astoria and these Astoria West sandals are sized differently and you can probably wear your usual size in these.Hope this helps. Great shoes!
✔ Verified Purchase
Z
Zeushi
September 27, 2025
Great sandal very comfortable
Keen are great. I ordered these the name for I left for cruise they arrived prior to my departure they were so comfortable they never needed to be broken and I wore them the whole week I highly recommend this product. Worth every penny of the price.
✔ Verified Purchase
