J
Jessica S.
January 08, 2026
Cute, Stiff Mary Janes With Misleading Materials
Classic chunky Mary Jane style with a square toe and double buckle straps. The black color is even and polished, slightly glossy, reads clean in indoor and outdoor light. The butterfly-shaped perforations on the toe are a nice detail.Upper feels firm and plastic-like, not leather. No grain, no flex, and no material info. No info on box either beyond a barcode. If it were leather, it would be labeled.True to size in length, but the straps run short. I have average feet with no swelling and needed the loosest buckle. If you’re between sizes or have a higher instep, sizing up is safer.Arch support is minimal. The sole is very stiff, especially at the ball of the foot. A couple of stick-on cushions are included, which helps slightly but also signals limited built-in comfort. Better for short wear than all-day use.
✔ Verified Purchase
C
Constance
December 28, 2025
Sharp looking two-tone oxford shoes with roomy toe box
I've always liked this two-tone style of lace up Oxford shoes. It's nice to find a pair with a moderately built up sole and heel, and a lot of room in the toe box.My everyday shoes are athletic shoes in a size 9.5, with a heavy sock for cushioning, and a supportive insole. I ordered these in a size 9 knowing I wouldn't be wearing as much sock, but not wanting to size down too far.These are roomy, but I don't think I could have gone with an 8.5. They fit comfortably and do not press on my toes anywhere. The heel cup is good, it comes up high enough and is structured. It has some padding for comfort shaping. I have narrow heels and these fit unexpectedly well in the heel. Not perfect but better than I thought they would or could.There is some cushioning, and the sole material itself is resilient. They should be very comfortable standing and walking at an event. The heel is substantial, it's higher than I'm used to but because the sole is thick as well, the heel drop is very moderate. They do not give you any feeling of wearing high heels.My intended purpose for these shoes is to make them the foundation of an outfit to wear to the horse races. I used to love getting dressed up for the racetrack, and haven't had the opportunity for a while. I look forward to the next time, and to building a little spectator wardrobe around these shoes.The only drawback to these shoes is the synthetic material of the upper. My feet sweat, and I haven't ever worn synthetic shoes much at all, because they don't breathe. If I wear these all day I might carry a couple of pairs of low no-show socks with me and change into dry ones as the day goes on. That would be a good solution, these shoes are very sharp, just my taste for the racetrack spectator occasion, and worth finding a way to wear them comfortably.
✔ Verified Purchase
K
Kimberly Ibanez
January 08, 2026
Order a half size up
These are very cute shoes. I usually can wear a 6.5 with pantyhose or very thin socks, a size 7 if I plan on wearing regular socks, which was what I was thinking, so I got the size 7. They barely fit on my bare foot. If you're ordering these, order a 1/2 size up at least. I think I can get away with wearing them with thin socks though. Also the toe part is much wider than the product photos they show here. They're not as even as they appear in the photos, they widen up a bit just at the toe part, but they're still cute, and comfortable. Non-slip as far as I can see. Can't wait until the spring when I can really wear them.
✔ Verified Purchase
P
Popeye’s Olive Oyl
January 05, 2026
Perfect black shoes and comfy for lots of different occasions
I love these vegan leather shoes!➕-True to size. I am a 7.5 with a medium wide foot and they fit perfectly-The buckle detailing is timeless and is also easy to fasten-The grip on the sole is decent-The heel has a different grip to the rest of the sole and is great for slippery conditions-The toe box is wide but not too wide allowing your toes some wiggle room-The heel doesn’t pinch-Slightly cushiony in the arch-Comes well packed with form fitted styrofoam to ensure they don’t lose shape when storing them➖-Just me being a bit nit picky but slightly more cushioning in the arch would be perfect. Still I can’t complain as they are very comfy.I did a lot of walking in these the first couple of days I got theses I didn’t get any blisters and they wore well. They’re good value for money compared to comparable name brands.They work well with my jeans and I wore them to church with a boho type skirt and got lots of compliments. These would work well with some wide legged pants for work. They have enough height to replace heels without feeling like they’re ridiculous.
✔ Verified Purchase
Y
Yasmine Springs
January 05, 2026
I love this style
These are a very super cute and great pair of Oxford shoes. They are a tad tight when first wearing but after wearing and breaking them in they are more comfortable to wear for long periods of time. They are very solid and durable so you can wear these for long periods. These are a great pair for price and the style is unmatched. The arch support could be tad better but like I said after wearing a few times they feel better. I still love these shoes and the style.
✔ Verified Purchase
Looks nice and is practical.
The shoes are very well made. The material of the sole of the shoe is thick and durable with a good tread to it and nice shape. The material of the shoe is very well selected for the style, it is thick without being to stiff. The buckle easily secures in place with little effort but does not come undone unintentionally. The stitching is even and we'll done with no loose threads or flaws. It comes with inserts that you can place to fit your particular foot shape. The shoes were the correct size, and fit nicely with the ability to adjust the straps as needed. They look nice enough to be used as a nicer dress up shoe, or for everyday at school. For the quality of material and look I would not hesitate in purchasing these at the price point.
✔ Verified Purchase
