M
Millenial Bird Dad
July 07, 2025
My Wife Loves These Stylish and Comfy Mary Janes
My wife has a cool, alternative sense of style and had been looking for a good pair of chunky platform Mary Janes for ages. I decided to surprise her with these for our anniversary, and I'm happy to report they were a huge hit right out of the box.Getting the size right was my biggest worry. She has pretty average-width feet, so based on the seller's advice, I ordered her usual size and they fit her perfectly. She was most impressed with the comfort. She said that even though the heel is over 2.5 inches, the chunky platform makes them feel much lower and very stable to walk in. We went out for dinner and a walk downtown, and she wore them for hours with no complaints about sore feet, which is rare for a new pair of heels.They look fantastic on her. The style is exactly that "Gothic" vibe she loves – they're chunky and bold but still look really well-made. She's already excited to pair them with everything from dresses to jeans. It can be a gamble buying shoes as a gift, but these were a definite win. She's thrilled with the look, and I'm thrilled she found a stylish pair of shoes she can actually be comfortable in.
✔ Verified Purchase
E
Evelyn Correa
May 05, 2025
Quality/Price
⭐️⭐️⭐️☆☆ Cute Aesthetic, but Quality Falls ShortI was drawn to these Mary Janes for their unique blend of gothic and Lolita fashion elements. The chunky heel and platform provide a stylish lift, and the single ankle strap adds a charming touch. They pair well with various outfits, from dresses to jeans, making them a versatile addition to my wardrobe.However, after wearing them a few times, I encountered some issues:Strap Durability: The ankle strap began to show signs of wear quickly. Some users have reported that the straps broke or the embellishments came unglued after minimal use.Comfort Concerns: The insole lacks cushioning, making extended wear uncomfortable. Additionally, the materials used feel cheap, and the shoes emit a strong chemical smell upon unboxing.Sizing Issues: The shoes run small. I recommend ordering at least a half size up, especially if you have wider feet. Some users also noted that the straps can be tight, so adjusting them carefully is essential.In summary, while these shoes score high on style, they fall short in terms of quality and comfort. If you're considering them for occasional wear and are willing to make some adjustments, they might be a suitable choice. However, for regular use, investing in a higher-quality pair would be advisable.
✔ Verified Purchase
T
Trudy Hart
October 05, 2025
Poor Quality
Item came packed in a plastic envelope. One shoe had a major dent on the front toe. My granddaughter wore them for 10 minutes in the house and the strap tore off. We are returning them. Definitely not worth the money. This is the second pair we have ordered. The first pair also came with dents and were returned.
✔ Verified Purchase
C
Citlali Garrido
October 16, 2025
Size up
The shoes are very cute and comfortable however size up I had ordered a 6.5in women’s and it was way too small had to get a 7 instead mind you I have flat wide feet as well
✔ Verified Purchase
Cute chunky heel Mary janes
Cute chunky heel Mary janes. True to size. This pair didn’t come in a box but it was wrapped well in plastic; double wrapped. The outer material was smooth. The color was black as stated. Shoe overall wasn’t too heavy.
✔ Verified Purchase
F
Freddielyle
April 23, 2025
Inconsistent fit and quality
Finally settled on our third pair. The first pair was way too big though we ordered her typical size. The second pair was a half size down and still too big. The third pair (another half size down) is closer to a decent fit, but still a little off-kind of wide and high while being the correct length. We got two pairs with buckle closure and one with Velcro. The Velcro closure strap was overly long. The buckles worked out better. The soles of these shoes are not rubber, so the grip isn’t as good as you might think. The upper portion of the pair we finally chose to keep is dented in on the top. It doesn’t interfere with wear, but it’s noticeable. We will try to fix it. Quality control seems to be a bit of an issue with these. The style is really cute though.
✔ Verified Purchase
G
GregD128
January 05, 2026
Classic and timeless design
Classic style and looks nice. Also quite comfortable to wear. Great for formal events such as concert performance for my kid, no complain about her for being hurt.
✔ Verified Purchase
